
CBS'WatsonIs a Chaotic Yet Intriguing Spin on Sherlock Holmes
The premiere of Watson on CBS brings an unexpected and somewhat bizarre twist to the classic Sherlock Holmes universe. Set in Pittsburgh, the show introduces Dr. John Watson (played by Morris Chestnut), who resumes his medical career as the head of a clinic dedicated to treating rare disorders. This new chapter comes after the tragic death of his close friend and partner, Sherlock Holmes, at the hands of the notorious Moriarty. Despite his efforts to move on, Watson’s past refuses to stay buried, and soon he finds himself caught up in a twisted web of mystery, with Moriarty still lurking in the shadows.
What makes this show so intriguing is its fusion of two very different genres. The first part of Watson resembles a typical medical procedural, where Watson and his team of quirky doctors diagnose perplexing medical conditions in a Pittsburgh clinic. The second part, however, delves into the much-loved Sherlockian mythology. These two storylines, while seemingly mismatched, combine in a way that both confounds and fascinates viewers. The procedural aspect is straightforward enough, offering the standard medical mystery formula. But when the show dips into Sherlock’s world, it gets chaotic in a way that is both absurd and darkly amusing.
The story kicks off with a dramatic and familiar moment: Watson follows Sherlock and Moriarty into the water at Reichenbach Falls, a scene that fans of the original stories will recognize. However, only Watson survives, emerging from the ordeal with a traumatic brain injury. Returning to his hometown of Pittsburgh, he uses the money Sherlock left him to open a medical clinic specializing in diagnostic mysteries. Alongside him is Shinwell Johnson (played by Ritchie Coster), a former associate of Sherlock’s, who now works as an administrator at the clinic. Watson also receives cases from his ex-wife, Dr. Mary Morstan (Rochelle Aytes), who is now the chief at a local hospital. These familiar dynamics set the stage for a story that feels both fresh and formulaic.
Also Read:- Tense Draw Leaves Burnley and Leeds in Promotion Battle Limbo
- Jimmy Butler Suspended Indefinitely by Miami Heat Amid Ongoing Tensions
While the medical aspect of the show is fine, it often feels secondary to the much more intriguing and ridiculous developments involving Sherlock’s legacy. The introduction of Moriarty, played by Randall Park, is especially eye-catching. Park’s portrayal of the classic villain is a departure from the usual sinister depictions, bringing a level of charm and pleasantness that makes him an even more unsettling character. The revelation of Moriarty’s plans for Watson’s clinic adds a sense of danger to the otherwise mundane medical cases.
However, it’s clear that Watson struggles with balancing its two tones. The show’s medical drama often feels generic and unremarkable, while its attempts to delve into the world of Sherlock Holmes are more hit-or-miss. The chemistry between the characters, especially Watson and Shinwell, is often overshadowed by the show’s attempt to weave in Holmes mythology, resulting in a jarring experience for the audience.
Despite these issues, Watson has moments that draw you in, particularly thanks to Morris Chestnut’s charismatic performance. His portrayal of Watson is refreshingly different from previous versions, exuding a swagger that makes him stand out in the traditionally stoic role. Whether or not the show will be able to keep its audience engaged remains uncertain, as its blend of medical mystery and Sherlockian intrigue is both entertaining and perplexing.
In the end, Watson is a bold and odd experiment that may not always succeed, but its unique combination of genres and chaotic storytelling makes it one of the most unpredictable shows of 2025. If you're in the mood for something unconventional and can embrace its silliness, Watson might just be the show for you.
Read More:
0 Comments